If you’ve never had a mac n cheese grilled cheese sandwich, then you’ve never really lived. It’s exactly what it sounds like: creamy macaroni and cheese stuffed into a sandwich with extra sharp cheddar and grilled until melty inside and golden browned to perfection on the outside. Some of you skeptic, health-conscious folk might be thinking that’s just way too much starch in one sandwich. WRONG! Those were my initial thoughts too, but alas, that is not the case. The starchy side and the sandwich aspect work harmoniously well together, creating a euphoric eating experience unlike any other. It’s a fusion of the ultimate comfort foods that results in a beautiful soul food hybrid. This, my friends, is heaven.
This recipe makes two sandwiches at once. Needing more than that? Just double the recipe as needed. I’ve always got to make 3 ‘batches’. Wanting to dial back the cheesiness a bit? You can opt out of adding the extra slices of cheddar? Even the cheese is flexible? Don’t like cheddar? American works well. Prefer a white cheddar macaroni and cheese? Use white cheddar slices, or even mozzarella or provolone. Cheese is very forgiving.
If you’ve tried this GRILLED MACARONI & CHEESE SANDWICH, or any other recipe on the site, let me know in the comment section how it turned out, we love hearing from our readers! You can also follow along with me on PINTEREST, FACEBOOK, and INSTAGRAM to see more amazing recipes and whatever else we’ve got going on!
Ingredients
- 4 slices Sourdough or other dense bread
- 1½ cups leftover Macaroni & Cheese
- 8 slices American or Cheddar Cheese
- 2 tbsp Butter
Instructions
- In a small nonstick skillet place heat ¾ cup of mac & cheese over medium heat.
- Once warm (about 3-4 minutes), shape mac & cheese into a pile about the size of the bread and top with 2 slices of cheese.
- Turn off heat.
- Butter 2 slices of bread.
- Place bread butter side down in another skillet over medium heat.
- Top one of the bread slices with 2 slices of cheese.
- Use a spatula to lift a corner and check done-ness.
- When lightly browned turn off heat. Use spatula to transfer mac & cheese rectangle onto cheese covered bread in the skillet.
- Cover with the other bread slice, toasted side up. Gently press together with spatula and transfer to a plate.
- Serve immediately.
Nutrition
Evelyn says
This looks outrageously delicious!!
4 Sons 'R' Us says
Thanks, Evelyn! We were lovin’ it.
Tracy says
Two of my favorite cheese dishes merged into one?! Fantastic! Happy Fiesta Friday! 😀
4 Sons 'R' Us says
It’s life altering.
Stephanie @ The Cozy Cook says
So, I’m literally sitting here… eating mac & cheese… REALLY delicious mac & cheese. And RIGHT before i saw your post I thought “I’ve GOT to try this in a grilled cheese sometime…” and then POOF, this post appeared. Kinda freaky. Needless to say, I’m definitely going to be trying this. It has The Cozy Cook written all over ittttt! I’ve been a fan of your grilled cheese variations for a while now!! 🙂 Happy Fiesta Friday Meaghan!
4 Sons 'R' Us says
If this doesn’t scream cozy cook, nothing could Stephanie. It should be right up your alley. Who knows, maybe we’ve got a little inner blog telepathy thing going on?
Liz @ spades, spatulas, and spoons says
I love the combination of creamy and toasty! This would be even better than mac and cheese pizza.
4 Sons 'R' Us says
It’s a pretty close match. We love our Mac N Cheese pizza recipe. Both are pretty epic recipes.
Andrea Giang | Cooking with a Wallflower says
Um, whoa! Mac and cheese in a sandwich?! This might just have to be my new comfort food. Thanks for sharing on FF, Meaghan!
4 Sons 'R' Us says
You’re welcome, Andrea. So glad you like it 🙂
Michelle @ Giraffes Can Bake says
wow, this has got to be illegal!!! There’s way too much comfort in that sandwich, I feel like I shouldn’t look directly at it or I’ll go into a deep slumber haha! But on a serious note, it looks soooo yummy and the ultimate in comfort food!
4 Sons 'R' Us says
If not illegal, that much comfort in one sandwich, let alone one bite, should definitely be regulated Michelle. Aren’t we lucky it’s not?!
Miz Helen says
What a great idea, your Mac N Cheese looks so good. Hope you are having a great day and thanks so much for sharing this awesome post with Full Plate Thursday.
Come Back Soon!
Miz Helen
Ann Harris says
Do you brown the 4 slices of buttered bread all at the same time? Or just make one sandwich at a time. Is the 1 1/2 cups of Mac & Cheese enough for 2 sandwiches? Or just one sandwich?