Name: Homemade Pierogi Recipe
Prep time: 60 min
Cook time: 30 min
Total time: 90 min
Ingredients: 2 cups flour; 1 tsp salt; 2 tsp butter (melted); 1 cup sour cream; 1 egg; 4 russet potatoes (peeled & quartered); 2 cups shredded sharp cheddar cheese (+ more for garnish); 2 tbsp butter (softened); 1/2 tsp onion powder; 1/4 tsp garlic powder; salt & pepper (to taste); 1 stick butter; 2 cloves garlic (minced); 1 tbsp fresh rosemary (chopped)

Jump to Recipe

This homemade pierogi recipe creates pillowy pockets of dough filled with a fluffy mashed potato center. The tender homemade dough will melt in your mouth. These cheese and potato pierogies are delicious served on their own, made into a casserole, or as a side to dishes like kielbasa and sauerkraut.

Pierogies are a favorite in my family. But really, what’s not to love about a potato and cheese dumpling? Nothing in my opinion. When you stuff a carb inside another carb you get perfection. It’s a mathematical, scientific fact that of course you will end up with little bites of heaven. While yes, you can buy frozen premade pierogies they are nothing compared to the real homemade deal.

What is a pierogi anyway?

If you’re not familiar with pierogies, they are sort of like the eastern European take on ravioli. By that I mean that pierogies are two sheets of filled noodle dough, pressed together around a filling.

Ravioli is generally filled with ricotta cheese or a meat mixture, but a fluffy mashed potato generally is inside a pierogie. You can also find homemade pierogi recipes stuffed with combinations of potato and cheese like this homemade pierogie recipe, sometimes sauerkraut, and even fruit for a sweeter spin.

Making this homemade pierogie recipe is a bit time consuming but it isn’t difficult. Plus, the results are well worth your efforts because you’ll be rewarded with the best homemade pierogi recipe ever.

And even better, you can fill them with whatever your little heart desires! And for me that’s a cheesy mashed potato.

Make the Homemade Pierogie Dough

To start making homemade pierogies, the first thing you need to do is make the dough. Just like my homemade pizza dough, this pierogie dough needs only a few simple ingredients. However, unlike my pizza dough, this dough doesn’t have any yeast so you don’t need to devote and time to letting it rise.

For the dough you need only a handful of basic ingredients:

flour
melted butter
salt
sour cream
an egg

If you don’t care for sour cream, you can substitute an equal amount of Greek yogurt. If you go this route though, make sure that you are using plain, full fat Greek yogurt and not flavored yogurt.

It’s easy to accidentally grab vanilla Greek yogurt instead of the plain stuff. Trust me. I learned that lesson the hard way!

That’s it! Nothing complicated! No yeast, so need to be intimidated by making this easy pierogie dough. Just add the dough ingredients to a bowl and mix them together with a spoon until they come together and form a dough.

Then knead the dough in the bowl with your hands for just a couple minutes. You want the flour to be fully incorporated with the rest of the ingredients, but you don’t want the dough to sit out for too long or it will dry out.

Once you’re done kneading the dough, cover it with a damp paper towel and let it rest for half an hour. While the dough is resting, this is the perfect time for you to start making the potato filling.

The Yummiest Cheesy Pierogie Filling!

Now that you’ve got your dough hanging out and resting, you can make the potato filling, which is essentially a cheddar mashed potato. I’m using a similar but thicker mashed potato to the ones I use in my copycat KFC Famous Bowls.

You can really use any mashed potato variation you like, and if you have leftover mashed potatoes in your fridge then you can use those for this pierogi filling instead. I adore any recipe that gives me a yummy way to reuse leftovers.

If you don’t happen to have leftover mashed potatoes, this basic cheddar mashed potato filling is easy and delicious. To make it, peel and cube your Russet potatoes. Then boil them until they are fork tender.

Once the potatoes are tender, drain the water and add the hot potato cubes into the bowl of a stand mixer with the paddle attachment. Add the butter, cheese, and spices to the potatoes and let the mixer work its magic until the potatoes are perfectly smooth.

If you want a creamier filling, feel free to mix in some a few tablespoons of softened cream cheese to your potatoes. If you for some reason don’t want cheese in your pierogi, then you can totally omit the cheese. Whatever you like.

Assembling the Pierogi

Now that you have the filling made and the dough ready to put the pierogies together. To do this, start by rolling out the dough on a very floured surface. You want the dough to be an 1/8″ of an inch thick.

Once you have the dough rolled out to the right thickness, use a 3″ biscuit cutter to cut the dough into circles. If you don’t have a biscuit cutter, you can use the top of a mason jar in a pinch.

Once you have the dough cut out, you can spoon 2 teaspoons of filling into the center of each dough circle. Then brush water around the edges of the circle and fold the dough in half, surrounding the potato filling with the dough. The folded pierogi will be in a half moon shape.

Press the edges of your pierogi to seal it or press a fork around the edges for that crimped look. However you choose to seal the pierogi, just make sure to press out all the air as you do so.

Once all the pierogies are sealed, you can boil them in small batches. They cook really quick. It only takes 1-2 minutes before the pierogies will float to the top, letting you know they are done. When you’ve got the pierogies cooked, you can toss them in the browned butter rosemary sauce or any other sauce you’d like.

Serving Suggestions for the Best Homemade Pierogi Recipe

While I love this homemade pierogie recipe served as is, drenched in the rosemary brown butter, you can do so many things with these pierogies.

For starters, you can fry them in oil or bake them in the oven after you boil them for a crispier finish. If you choose to cook them like that, they will be more like the pierogies you can find at fairs and festivals.

You can also change up your toppings. They would be delicious topped with caramelized onions or served up with sauerkraut and kielbasa or with this delicious caramelized sauerkraut and beer bratwurst.

If you want a simpler topping, you could top them with sour cream. Or you could get crazy and dunk them into cheese sauce because cheddar makes everything better.

Freeze This Kid Friendly Favorite!

Lastly, I like to make big batches of these homemade pierogies and freeze them.

To freeze these pierogies and save for a later date, don’t cook them after you have them filled and sealed. Instead, place the sealed uncooked pierogi on a wax paper lined baking sheet. Freeze them for 30 minutes. Then, remove them from the freezer and gently place them in a ziplocking freezer bag.

Securely sealed with any excess air removed, they can be stored in the freezer for up to three months. Just remove the desired amount and plug them into the recipe of your choosing or heat them up for an after school snack for your kids.

I love to keep them on hand to use in these recipes:

Anyway you make or serve this homemade pierogi recipe, you’ll never buy a frozen pierogi again!

If you’ve tried these HOMEMADE PIEROGI RECIPE, or any other recipe on my site, let me know in the comment section how it turned out, we love hearing from our readers! You can also follow along with me on PINTEREST, FACEBOOK, and INSTAGRAM to see more amazing recipes and whatever else we’ve got going on!