Thanksgiving Leftover Sandwiches with Cranberry Mayo

Thanksgiving leftover sandwiches with cranberry mayonnaise use up your remaining turkey and stuffing after the holiday. No one will complain eating leftovers when they are served like this!

We always have enough food to feed an army leftover after the holidays.

Especially after Thanksgiving.

I always have a mountain of turkey and stuffing left.

And it is a shame to let it go to waste.

So Thanksgiving leftover sandwiches it is!

We’re talking tender turkey, savory leftover stuffing, fluffy brioche buns, and a tangy cranberry mayo.

So good!

Ingredients

To make these turkey and stuffing sandwiches you need:

• Leftover turkey– Slice it up and warm it.
• Stuffing– Warm it up.
• Brioche buns– Sliced in half and toasted.
• Butter – Optional, but highly recommended for toasting up golden delicious sandwich buns.
• Cheese – Shredded white cheddar cheese, for melting onto the buns while they toast. A chef’s kiss pairing with the cranberry mayo and other sandwich ingredients.
• Mayonnaise– Do not substitute Miracle Whip. And make sure you use a quality mayonnaise like Hellman’s or Dukes.
• Cranberry sauce– Either store bought or homemade. Whatever you have left.
• Half and half– To thin the cranberry mayo, but only if needed.

How to Make

This sandwich is just the thing to make to use up your leftovers from a day spent in the kitchen. It needs virtually no work!

To make it, warm up your leftover turkey and stuffing.

While they’re heating toast your sliced brioche buns.

Add them all to a sheet pan, insides up.

We like to spread some butter on the insides, and sprinkle shredded white cheddar over before toasting them. It’s a little something extra that really takes the whole sandwich a step above.

Then bake them in the oven just until golden brown and toasty and the cheese has melted.

Remove from the oven & set aside.

Then make the cranberry mayonnaise by whisking the cranberry sauce and mayo together in a small bowl until evenly combined.

If the sauce is too think for your liking, stir in a teaspoon or two of half and half. 

Set the mayo aside.

Then, layer the warm turkey slices on the bottoms of your brioche buns and top the turkey with a generous serving of warm stuffing.

Spread cranberry mayo on the bottom of the top bun, then add it to close the sandwiches.

Serve and enjoy!

What is a Thanksgiving leftover sandwich called?

One of the most well known Thanksgiving leftover sandwiches is called The Bobbie.

My recipe is a variation on that.

Can I Save Leftover Cranberry Mayo Sauce?

As written the recipe only makes two sandwiches, although it’s easy to double or triple the amount as needed.

If you have extra cranberry mayo, store it in an airtight container.

Refrigerate and use within 3 days.

Tips and Tricks

• I prefer my sandwiches without mashed potatoes and gravy, but my kids swear by a layer of mashed potatoes and also a schmear of gravy on the bottom bun.
• DO NOT substitute miracle whip for mayo. Also use a quality mayo that you like since it’s the base of your sandwich’s sauce.
• Want to add a little green and crunch? Top the sandwiches with a couple romaine or bibb lettuce leaves.

Other Ways to Use Up Thanksgiving Leftovers

Thanksgiving leftover sandwiches are an easy and delicious way to use up your holiday leftovers. Make them this year and enjoy!

Looking for other ways to use up Thanksgiving leftovers? Try these:

• Thanksgiving Leftover Crescent Roll Bake
• Grilled Mac & Cheese Sandwich
• Crispy Mashed Potato & Stuffing Pancakes
• Thanksgiving Leftover Egg Rolls with Cranberry Dipping Sauce
• Chicken & Stuffing Stuffed Shells
• Macaroni & Cheese Egg Rolls

If you’ve tried this THANKSGIVING LEFTOVER SANDWICHES, or any other recipe on the site, let me know in the comment section how it turned out, we love hearing from our readers! You can also follow along with me on PINTEREST, FACEBOOK, and INSTAGRAM to see more amazing recipes and whatever else we’ve got going on!